QHRtechworx
QHRtechworx

Recruiters or Candidates: Who is ghosting who!!

Cover

Recruiters are pulling their hair out—what’s left of it, anyway. Why? Because some candidates vanish into thin air after accepting an offer, only to reappear on the joining day with a cheerful, “Actually, I’ve gone with another opportunity. Thanks, though!”

Meanwhile, candidates are howling in frustration: “I’ve applied to 1,000’s of jobs, rewritten my resume ten times, sacrificed a goat to the algorithm gods—and still not a single call!”

Having spent over 25 years in recruitment, managing large, multi-location operations, I’ve seen this saga unfold and have had to de-escalate the situation from taking ugly turns on multiple occasions. The frustration is real—and the arrival of AI hasn't helped; it just made the mess fancier!

Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), now AI-powered, were meant to make life easier. Instead, we’re wading through keyword-stuffed resumes designed to trick the system. Many of them are beautifully optimized for machines, but barely make sense to humans. And when we do speak to the person behind the resume, it turns out they’re nowhere close to being a fit. More interviews, more time wasted, more recruiter burnout. Yay, productivity?

Candidates are tailoring their resumes like they’re building a secret weapon—not to tell their story, but to outsmart the bot. But here’s the thing: resumes that rise to the top of the ATS don’t always rise to the top of the hiring list. The result is more screening, more dead-ends, and a lot of collective sighing on the recruiter floor.

Here’s a classic case: We’re hiring a Java developer in city A. The job clearly states: in-office three days a week. A candidate from city B applies, looks great on paper, but isn’t open to relocating. Do we owe them a response? In theory, yes. But in reality, when you’re screening 300 resumes and 50 of them have similar misalignments, the inbox becomes a black hole of well-meaning intentions.

Hiring, in my view, should never come from a place of authority. As recruiters, we’re not here to reject—we’re here to find reasons to say “yes.” But candidates have to help us get there. That means showcasing relevant experience, results delivered, and skills that actually match the role. And no, “passionate team player” doesn’t count unless you can show what impact that passion had.

At the same time, I get it—candidates are under pressure. The economy is shaky, and job seekers are playing the numbers game. Apply to enough roles, and something might stick. But if you’re applying for every job under the sun, regardless of fit, hoping for a miracle… you’re just clogging up the system. And let’s be honest, no one ever won a job lottery with “Ctrl+C, Ctrl+V.”

Instead of tweaking resumes to beat the ATS, candidates should focus on standing out for the right reasons. Show how your skills solve real problems. Demonstrate what you’ve done, not just what you claim to know. If the role is about scaling revenue, talk numbers. If it’s about people leadership, talk outcomes. Be specific. Be credible. Be human.

Not long ago, one of my clients wanted a second opinion on a sales candidate. The resume looked great—the candidate had apparently closed deals with companies that were on my client’s target list. Sounds perfect, right? But the details revealed otherwise: the candidate had sold small-ticket items to mid-level managers. My client was expecting million-dollar contracts with C-level execs. Could the candidate grow into that? Maybe. But the ramp-up time would be 12–18 months. The reality? The client needed someone who could hit the ground running, not someone learning how to walk that path.

In the end, the hiring process works best when both sides are honest and aligned. Recruiters should be transparent about what they’re looking for. Candidates should apply when they meet the requirements—and know when to pass if they don’t.

Let’s stop making hiring feel like a bad dating app experience—full of ghosting, mismatches, and awkward small talk. Clear expectations, relevant applications, and genuine communication can go a long way. We may not have solved the mystery of the perfect hire, but we can at least agree: less fluff, more fit, and please—fewer AI tricks. Let the robots help, not hinder.

Until then, may your inbox be light, your interviews be insightful, and your next hire—or job—be the right one.